Blog

Profit Surge Trader Review: Is Nate Bear Legit?

Our editorial team uses a strict editorial review process to compile all reviews, research, and evaluations of any kind. Our company, WallStreetZen Limited, is supported by our user community and may receive a small commission when purchases are made through partner links. Commissions do not affect the opinions or evaluations of our editorial team.

There’s no fast-forward button to profits in investing. (Sorry.)

However, following an established expert can potentially uplevel your results. 

That’s where stock advice services like Profit Surge Trader come into play. 

With a straightforward strategy and compelling backstory, this stock-picking service certainly paints a compelling picture of capitalizing on profits in a short amount of time. But is it really all that?

In this Profit Surge Trader review, I’ll examine the program from all angles to see if it’s legit and worth your time — and present some worthy alternatives that may be better suited to more risk-averse investors.

Let’s go: 

Is Profit Surge Worth It?

I won’t keep you in suspense. If you’re looking for ways to make quick trades and don’t mind the heightened volatility of options, Profit Surge Trader might be right for you.

However, it’s important to note that there aren’t many third-party Profit Surge Trader reviews, making this service more speculative than established offerings. Of course, this is partially offset by a 365-day refund program.

If you prefer the simplicity of stocks and want to avoid volatility, you’ll find an excellent (and more wallet-friendly) alternative in Zen Investor, a stock-picking newsletter that focuses on stocks with long-term potential. 

A more affordable alternative…

With a Zen Investor subscription, you can save precious research time and let a 40+ year market veteran do the heavy lifting for you. Here’s what you get:

✅ Portfolio of up to 30 of the best stocks for the long haul, hand-selected by Steve Reitmeister, former editor-in-chief of Zacks.com with a 4-step process using WallStreetZen tools

✅ Monthly Commentary & Portfolio Updates

✅ Sell Alerts if the thesis changes

✅ Members Only Webinars

✅ 24/7 access to all the elements noted above

✅ Access to an archive of past trades and commentary.

Get started with Zen Investor for $79 today

What is the Profit Surge Trader Program?

Profit Surge Trader is a stock advice service created by the trader Nate Bear and the company Monument Traders Alliance.

The basic premise? To capitalize on momentum during earnings season for outsized gains.  

With his “One Ticker Payouts” strategy, Nate chooses one stock that just crushed earnings and has the potential to continue rising (or “surging”) in the succeeding weeks. 

Here’s what’s different: Rather than buying stocks directly, Nate only recommends options.

Why? 

Options are more volatile than underlying stocks. So, you could potentially make a lot more moolah if the trade is right.  

1. Profit Surge Trader Best Deal

As a member of Profit Surge Trader, you get access to monthly stock picks on Nate’s radar, weekly trade alerts, and live trading sessions to help prepare for these positions. 

Who is Nate Bear? 

OK, that sounds interesting, but should you trust this Nate Bear guy? 

The Nate Bear trading strategy starts with a fascinating backstory…

2. Profit Surge Trader Weekly Trader's Lunch with Nate Bear

A construction grad from Georgia Tech, Nate Bear should know more about buildings than big money. 

However, Nate was determined to learn the art of day trading to escape the rat race and provide for his family.

Although Nate made a few missteps, he eventually found his footing and posted wild gains.

According to most Nate Bear Profit Surge Trader reviews, his greatest claim to fame is turning $37,000 to $2.7 million in just four years. 

Impressive, right?

So, even though Nate Bear doesn’t have insider connections on Wall Street, he’s certainly shown he knows how to manage money. 

Profit Surge: Key Features 

When you subscribe to Profit Surge Trader, you’ll get more than just monthly stock recommendations.

True, the solo ticker strategy is the hallmark of this service, but don’t fear you’ll be left alone in the market. 

Other features give you more insight into how to position your portfolio. 

One Ticker Payouts Live:

During these calls every Monday at 12 PM EST, you’ll hear from Nate on what he’s looking for in this month’s ticker and how he plans to enter and exit trades. These streams are also available as recordings if you can’t catch them at noon. 

Members-Only Chatroom:

In this private channel, you can gain more insight into stock trading and ask questions.

Weekly Trade Alerts:

Nate constantly lets the community know what he’s doing through emails, chatroom alerts, and push notifications. Nate aims to supply 52 hand-picked stocks over 12 months. 

S.A.M. Stock Picks:

Recently, Profit Surge Trader joined the AI revolution with its S.A.M. stock scanner. Using this AI-powered program, Nate plans to offer his readers an extra 52 stock recommendations. 

Private Training Library:

You could access a few eBooks on topics like options, Nate Bear’s trading tactics, and the One Ticker strategy, as well as video training resources like the Ten-Bagger Earnings Plays. 

365-Day Money Back Guarantee:

If after you review Profit Surge Trader you find it isn’t delivering the goods, you can request a refund within 365 days. Simply contact Profit Surge Trader’s customer service department and you should get your money back without a hassle. 

Is Profit Surge Legit? 

As far as the theory behind Profit Surge Trader, there’s a lot of credibility to profiting from companies with upside surprises. (Need proof? See the chart below.)

Even fancy-pants PhDs know about this phenomenon, so there’s a lot of academic credibility behind Nate’s strategy.  

3. Is Profit Surge Legit
Chart courtesy TradingView

However, it’s not super easy to get a straight answer about Profit Surge Trader’s performance. 

Why?

Most of the testimonials and records on Profit Surge Trader’s success appear to have been produced by the company itself, without clear verification.

For instance, Profit Surge Trader says it beat the broader markets by 1,700% with a 100% win rate in Q1 of 2024. 

Promotional material for Profit Surge Trader also claims some users were able to turn initial investments of around $1,000 to $19,870 or $45,000 in a few days or months. 

4. Profit Surge Trader Highlight

While these figures are impressive, it’s important to take them with a grain of salt in promotional materials.

There are also no Profit Surge Trader reviews on third-party sites like TrustPilot or the BBB. 

There also isn’t much data on Profit Surge Trader on forums like Reddit. 

But that doesn’t mean Profit Surge Trader isn’t legit. 

To be fair, there are several YouTube testimonials and other Nate Bear reviews that praise this service. As you review Profit Surge Trader, just remember that it’s still a relatively niche product without many external rankings. 

Profit Surge User Testimonials and Reviews

As mentioned above, most reviews for Profit Surge Trader come from Nate’s official webpage. 

So while these anecdotal testimonials make Nate Bear seem like Michael Burry, consider the source. 

Here’s a sampling of reviews: 

  • David: “I just turned 80… I resigned myself to working until my death, with no hope of paying off my debt and leaving my wife who is 20 years younger with anything. Then I came across Nate’s service and story. Frankly, it gave me hope. I have experienced more success with Nate and his community more than anywhere else.”
  • Stewart: “Nate has changed my trading life, from bouncing back and forth… to now up over 600% in 6 months.”
  • William: “Well worth the price, it paid for itself the first week. I have gone from knowing nothing about trading options to making 335 trades with an 86% win rate in seven months. Nate is a fantastic teacher and I have learned to find high-quality trades on my own in addition to the weekly service recommendations. This stuff is fun.”

Pricing and Subscription Options

You can expect to pay $997 annually for full access to Profit Surge Trader.

But this isn’t your only option to jump on Nate Bear’s trading train. 

All-Access Subscription:

The aforementioned $997 figure is for the All-Access subscription, which includes all the bonuses like an Options 101 playbook and the $2.7 Million Dollar Trading System Masterclass. 

Standard Account:

If you feel you don’t need Nate’s eBooks or video courses, you could pay $329 for the Standard account, which still gives you access to the Ten-Bagger Earnings Plays Video Training.

Basic Account:

Lastly, a Basic account for $249 gives you access to the Profit Surge Trade recommendations and weekly Ticker Payouts Live Streams (FYI: This annual fee goes up to $279 after the first year).  

But wait, there’s more!

For a limited time, Nate Bear is offering a welcome discount of $279 with the All-Access account. There’s no telling how long this Member Deal will last, so it may revert to $997 at any moment. 

No matter which plan you choose, keep in mind Profit Surge Trader offers a 365-money-back guarantee with all of its products. So if you’re interested in checking it out but don’t enjoy the service once you sign up, you can potentially recoup some of your investment. 

Alternatives to Consider

As enticing as Profit Surge Trader may sound, it’s far from the only stock-picking service. 

If you’ve decided Nate Bear’s trading playbook isn’t for you — or if you just want to explore alternatives — consider the below services:

1. Zen Investor

  • Cost: $79 for 1 year, $190 for 3 years, $197 for 5 years 
  • What You Get: Stock screeners, analyst insights, in-depth investment reports, and a portfolio of curated stock picks. 

For high-potential stock picks, it makes sense to trust a high-quality source, right?

That’s the strategy behind the Zen Investor subscription. 

6. What Do These Stocks Have in Common

With over 40 years of experience tracking the stock market for sites like Zacks.com, Zen Investor Editor-in-Chief Steve Reitmeister has plenty of knowledge on what to look for in an attractive investment. 

Add in the Zen Ratings system — which analyzes 115 factors in stocks to arrive at a simple-to-understand letter grade — and the chances for success are even higher. 

When a promising stock scores well with Zen Ratings, Steve Reitmeister starts investigating each opportunity for its potential upside. 

If a company passes these two rigorous screenings, it becomes a Zen Investor pick for members to take advantage of. 

Besides these 20 – 30 high-potential stock picks per year, subscribers to Zen Investor enjoy detailed market analysis and trading strategies. 

So, if you’re looking for rigorously vetted stock ideas, Zen Investor is a solid pick.

Alpha Picks

  • Cost: $499 per year
  • What You Get: Two new portfolio additions every month, sell alerts, ongoing performance updates, and webinars with a quant team. 

If you’re less interested in short-term gains and more interested in long-term investments, you may want to consider Alpha Picks, the stock-picking service offered by Seeking Alpha. With it, you get two high-conviction stock picks from Seeking Alpha’s team every month. 

Led by former Morgan Stanley trader Steven Cress, Alpha Picks’ quant team carefully reviews different stock opportunities and shares these names with their subscribers.

You can also learn more about each stock pick idea with detailed reports or by watching a webinar with the team. 

Alpha Picks claims to have helped investors beat the S&P 500 by over 3x. (Check out our Alpha Picks review here)

How Have We Achieved Outperformance

Just keep in mind these Alpha Picks are designed for those with a long-term buy-and-hold mentality rather than swing traders.

Mindful Trader

  • Cost: $47 per month
  • What You Get: Stock and options picks, tutorials behind stock and options trading strategies, and emails with commentary about current trades. 

Harnessing the powers of mathematics and mindfulness meditation, a Monterey-based man has put together a hot stock-picking service called Mindful Trader.

Mindful Trader

With a Mindful Trader subscription, you’ll get messages from pro trader Eric every time he takes on a new position with clearly defined rules on how to enter the trade.

Indeed, one of the key selling points of Mindful Trader is its mathematical precision. 

This guy has serious credentials with numbers, including a perfect SAT score and a degree from Stanford. 

Eric also frequently emphasizes the significance of backtesting in his positions. 

This heavy focus on algebraic analysis makes copying the Mindful Trader simple.

Just keep in mind that the Mindful Trader is for active day and swing traders rather than long-term investors. 

You have to be active in the market to implement these strategies and reap potential rewards. 

However, since this is a monthly subscription, you don’t have to pay as much to try it out, and you can cancel at any time.

Pros and Cons of Profit Surge Trader 

Pros
Cons
Easy-to-Follow Trades: Once you sign up for this subscription, all you have to do is pay attention to Nate Bear’s moves and copy his positions.
Lack of Trustworthy Profit Surge Trader Reviews 
Concentrates Capital and Attention: By concentrating on just one stock pick, it’s easier to monitor price activity, gauge profitability, and put maximum capital to work for outsized returns. 
Requires Active Monitoring: This isn’t a great service for people who don’t like watching stock prices every day. 
High-Conviction Strategy: While Nate Bear’s strategy misses the post-earning boom, it also avoids nasty drawdowns with unexpectedly poor earnings reports. 
Lack of Diversification: The downside of putting all your attention into one stock is there’s no buffer to cushion a loss. 
Educational Resources: New to options? Nate Bear has got you covered, with eBooks and watch videos on trading to get up-to-speed on everything you need to master this strategy. 
Solely Focuses on Options: Traders more comfortable with buying stocks directly will have a bit of a learning curve when working with this options-centric strategy. 
Generous Refund Program: Profit Surge Trader has one of the longest refund opportunities at 365 days post-purchase. 
Poor Choice for Long-Term Investors: Profit Surge Trader is solely for short-duration traders. 

Conclusion

So, what’s the final verdict on our Profit Surge Trader review? 

It depends on your trading preferences. 

If you’re looking for ways to make quick trades and don’t mind the heightened volatility of options, then this may be a worthwhile service.

Just keep in mind that there aren’t many third-party Profit Surge Trader reviews, making this service more speculative than established offerings. 

Still, with its 365-day refund program, you can at least get back your initial subscription charge. 

Bottom line: It may be worthwhile looking into Profit Surge Trader if you’re in the market to potentially profit from momentum trading. However, if you don’t like following every tick of a stock, you may prefer a service better suited for long-term investing, such as Zen Investor.


FAQs:

Who is Nate Bear the trader?

Nate Bear is a construction worker turned options trader who became a multi-millionaire thanks to his trading strategy. He now shares the principles he used to achieve financial independence through Profit Surge Trader.

Is Profit Surge legit?

Although there aren't many third-party reviews on Profit Surge Trader, it appears to be a legit service. However, it does come with a healthy level of risk, so make sure you're comfortable with the volatility of options and fast-paced trading before signing up.

What is the Profit Surge Trader Program?

The Profit Surge Trader Program is a stock subscription plan that shares monthly high-conviction option plays with its users. As a member of Profit Surge Trader, you get access to monthly stock picks on Nate's radar, weekly trade alerts, and live trading sessions to help prepare for these positions. 

What is the Profit Surge cost?

The All-Access Profit Surge Trader plan costs $997 per year, but you could get the Standard account for $329 or the Basic account for $249.

Where to Invest $1,000 Right Now?

Did you know that stocks rated as "Buy" by the Top Analysts in WallStreetZen's database beat the S&P500 by 98.4% last year?

Our February report reveals the 3 "Strong Buy" stocks that market-beating analysts predict will outperform over the next year.

Avatar photo

About the author

Eric Esposito

Contributor