This Controversial Stock is a Strong Buy

In investing, the best opportunities usually come with a story that sounds bad.

A note from our sponsors...

BP (NYSE: BP) has one of those stories.

Deepwater Horizon. A misguided pivot to renewables that alienated its core investors. Not to mention years of underperformance while Exxon and Chevron pulled away. It’s no mystery why Wall Street largely stopped paying attention … but that's exactly why it's worth paying attention now.

Our Zen Ratings system gives BP an A:

… But the Component that stands out isn't what you'd expect.

What Went Wrong, And Why It's Changing

Under former CEO Bernard Looney, BP made a dramatic bet on becoming a clean energy company. It slashed oil and gas investment, promised aggressive renewable targets, and repositioned itself as the ESG-friendly supermajor.

The market never bought it. Traditional energy investors sold. ESG investors didn't arrive to replace them. The stock drifted while peers compounded.

Now here’s why the script has flipped.

New leadership has course-corrected decisively. The strategy now explicitly targets upstream growth of 2.3 to 2.5 million barrels of oil equivalent per day by 2030, alongside more disciplined and selective low-carbon investments. It's not an abandonment of the energy transition, it's just a return to executing what BP actually does well, with the balance sheet to back it up. 

The previous era's strategic mistakes are being unwound quarter by quarter. But the market is still pricing in the penalty.

The Part Nobody Expects: BP Is a Growth Stock

Here's what makes the ratings surprising.

Our Zen Ratings system gives BP an A in Growth, meaning across 22 different growth metrics, including sales acceleration, EPS momentum, and margin improvement, BP is outperforming the vast majority of the 4,600-plus stocks we track.

Nobody thinks of BP as a growth story right now. That gap between perception and reality is the entire thesis.

Q1 2026 highlighted exceptional oil trading gains amid heightened crude price volatility, with upstream production guidance holding steady. The pivot is showing up in actual numbers.

Management Is Telling You Something

Throughout early 2026, BP has been running an aggressive share repurchase program, buying back billions in shares at current prices. The buyback program has been consistent and sustained, with the company repurchasing shares across multiple tranches throughout the first quarter.

When management buys aggressively at a steep discount to peers, that's a signal worth taking seriously. They're not waiting for the market to recognize the value. They're buying it themselves.

What Our Ratings Are Saying

BP scores an A overall: a Strong Buy in our system.

The A in Growth is the standout … unexpected for a company most investors still associate with the previous era's strategic drift. Bs across Momentum, Sentiment, and Safety round out a fundamentally sound profile. 

The B in our AI component grade adds another layer, with our system detecting improving patterns in market data that suggest price performance ahead.

The Cs in Value and Financials are worth addressing directly. I think they reflect transition costs and legacy overhead still working through the system, the residue of a strategic reset, not permanent structural problems. As the upstream pivot matures and margin improvement continues, those grades have room to move.

Click here to see all of BP’s Component Grades 

Bottom Line

BP is cheap relative to peers, growing faster than the market realizes, buying back stock aggressively, and executing a credible return to its core strengths.

The market is still pricing in the mistakes of a management team that no longer runs the company.

Our ratings say the gap between that perception and reality is closing.

[Add BP to your watchlist]

[See all top-rated Oil & Gas Integrated stocks]

What to Do Next?

• 77 Best Stocks NOW! >
• Options Trading with the Zen Ratings >
• 2 New Stocks to Buy from Steve Reitmeister >

Want to get in touch? Email us at news@wallstreetzen.com.