The Real Estate Stock Everyone Misunderstands

This might just be the most misunderstood real estate stock out there…

Comstock Holding Companies (NASDAQ: CHCI) scores a B, or “Buy,” according to our Zen Ratings system. Yet it trades at a P/E of about 7.

That sounds about right — if you think CHCI is a homebuilder. But here’s the thing: it used to be. It’s not anymore. 

And if you understand what the company is today, that valuation might start to look quite cheap.

A note from our sponsors...
Sleep well at night with 7 stellar stocks to buy and hold forever
  

Every powerhouse name on this list is already a proven winner. You won't find any risky moonshots, startups, or unicorns. Just best-in-class blue chips you can hold for years to come.  

Get the complete list FREE for a limited time.

Here’s what investors are missing when it comes to this small real estate stock with big catalysts. And why it’s our best-rated stock when it comes to diversified real estate companies.

From Swinging for the Fences to Clipping Coupons

Before 2018, CHCI was a typical small-cap home builder: highly cyclical, high leverage, boom/bust risk, housing-market dependent.

But after getting wrecked in the financial crisis and sputtering through the 2010s, CHCI did something rare for a public company: it completely reinvented itself.

In 2018, it ditched homebuilding and became a fee-based real estate asset manager. No more building. No more owning. No more huge risks.

Today, CHCI manages over 2.3 million square feet of commercial and residential property along the D.C. metro’s Dulles Corridor. It gets paid recurring fees to run leasing, construction, property management, and parking for these projects … most of which are owned by a private real estate firm co-owned by CHCI’s own insiders.

Why the Market Still Doesn’t Get It

Here’s the problem: CHCI is still priced like a “homebuilding” company. And that’s partly because the stock is so small that institutional investors don’t even cover it. It trades about 19,000 shares a day. So the stock gets lumped in with names that face totally different risks.

That explains the ~7x earnings multiple.

But this isn’t a homebuilder anymore. It’s closer to a real estate asset manager. And that changes everything.

Why Asset Managers Trade Higher (and Deserve To)

Asset-light businesses like CHCI — where capital doesn’t need to be reinvested into physical assets — are structurally better models. 

Here’s why:

• High Margins: Most of CHCI’s costs are fixed. As it adds square footage under management, profits grow faster than revenue.
• Low Risk: It doesn’t own buildings or take on construction debt. If a property sits half-empty, it still gets paid.
• Consistent Cash Flow: Long-term contract runs through 2035 and renews automatically. That’s a guaranteed stream of high-margin income.
• Scalable: The systems are in place. New properties just get layered on top.
• Tax-Efficient: ~$120M in net operating losses shelter much of its future profits.

The Mispricing = The Opportunity

This company should probably trade closer to 15–20x earnings, not 7x. Especially as profits look set to double over the next two years from the 5.6 million square feet of new developments already underway.

Even if the market only figures that out slowly, investors are still looking at:

• A rerating from P/E ~7 to ~15
• Earnings growth from ~$7M to potentially ~$14M
• A stock price target of $18–24 from today’s ~$10

That’s 100%+ upside on a relatively boring, low-risk, cash-generating operation.

Plus, CHCI currently scores a B for both Financials, and Momentum. Our Momentum Component Grade weighs things like volume-weighted momentum, risk-adjusted momentum, the volatility of price movements over time, and more. 

Click here to see how CHCI ranks across our other Component Grades.

Speaking of momentum, I’m personally looking to “buy the breakout” on this one, on a clean break and hold above ~$12.35 (yellow):

Bonus Catalysts

• ParkX (parking business): $9.5M+ in run-rate revenue and growing. Could be monetized separately.
• Tysons Casino Wildcard: A long-shot mixed-use project (with possible casino) is currently in lobbying stages. If it lands, CHCI will likely manage it — another fee stream.
• Share buybacks: Insiders own 66+% of the stock, dilution has slowed, and CHCI could start returning capital soon.

The Bottom Line?

CHCI is not what it used to be. It’s not a risky homebuilder. It’s not a REIT.

It’s a lean, quiet cash machine … an overlooked real estate operating business priced like a broken housing stock.

Dig into our quant ratings system’s 115-factor review on CHCI

What to Do Next?

• 200 Stocks to Sell Now >
• See All “A” Rated Stocks with +32.52% Average Annual Return >
• 2 New Stocks to Buy from Steve Reitmeister >

Want to get in touch? Email us at news@wallstreetzen.com.